top of page
Search

Should You Hire a Private Investigator for Litigation?

info0021020
Oct 28
7 min read

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

Quick Summary

Hiring a private investigator for litigation makes sense when facts that will decide your case are hard to reach through discovery alone, such as a missing witness or a claimant's activity that contradicts their injury claim. Bring the investigator in once you know which question needs answering, since evidence lost early can't be recovered.

  • Investigators are most useful when a witness has disappeared or a claimant's activity contradicts their injury claim.

  • Scope every task in writing before work begins so the attorney and investigator share the same goal.

  • Confirm the investigator's license, professional liability and general liability insurance before signing.

  • Run a written conflict check against opposing counsel, parties and insurers before any witness is interviewed.

  • Retain the investigator through the law firm and address reports to the attorney to protect work product.

Table of Contents

When a Private Investigator Makes Sense in a Lawsuit

Hiring a private investigator for litigation makes the most sense when the facts that will decide your case are hard to reach through discovery alone. Attorneys typically bring in an investigator when a witness has disappeared, when a claimant's physical activity contradicts their injury claim, or when opposing counsel's account needs independent verification. The investigator's job is to gather facts, document them, and hand your attorney the findings.

The question is whether the information gap justifies the cost. A simple contract dispute with clean paper trails rarely needs field work; a personal injury case with a disputed surveillance angle, a missing key witness, or a suspicious claim often does.

Watch out: an investigator hired too late may find that evidence has already been lost, witnesses have moved, or footage has been overwritten. Bring the investigator in once you know what question needs answering.

What Litigation Investigators Can Actually Do

Common tasks include background research, asset and address verification, witness interviews, document retrieval from public sources, and field observation. Each task should be scoped in writing before work begins, so both the attorney and the investigator know what evidence is being sought and why.

Locating Witnesses and Serving Papers

Serving papers is a separate skill. Improper service can void the process and delay the case. Investigators who handle service should document each attempt, including date, time, location, and the person served, because that record may be needed if service is challenged.

Surveillance for Legal Cases

Surveillance only helps if it is documented carefully. Logs should record start and end times, locations, weather, and conditions. Raw footage should be preserved unedited. Unexplained gaps or edits give opposing counsel an easy target. A common mistake is treating surveillance as a highlight reel instead of a complete record.

Making Sure the Evidence Can Be Used in Court

Investigators who understand litigation document as they go. For detailed guidance on authentication, chain of custody, and admissibility, see our guide to admissible surveillance evidence. They label files consistently, back up originals, and keep notes contemporaneous with the events they describe. The goal is to make the investigator's testimony straightforward when it comes time to testify.

Private investigator for litigation photographing a vehicle while documenting evidence on a Florida street.

Hiring a Licensed Private Investigator: Vetting Criteria

Most attorneys have never hired an investigator, and job boards do little to help them vet one. Treat the selection process like hiring an expert witness: you are not buying hours, you are buying testimony that will survive cross-examination. The framework below is built for litigation, not general investigative work.

Start with licensing and standing

Also confirm insurance. A professional liability policy and a general liability policy are baseline. An investigator without insurance is a cost-saving illusion: if the investigator is accused of trespass or misconduct during your case, you want a carrier standing behind the work.

Test for litigation experience, not investigative experience

  • What is your policy on retaining raw footage and field notes, and for how long? The answer should be a defined retention period and a defined storage method, not "as long as you need it."

Run a conflict check before you sign

Investigators work for many attorneys in the same market. Ask in writing whether the firm has worked for opposing counsel, the opposing party, or any insurer in the case. A conflict surfacing after the investigator has interviewed your witness is a malpractice exposure, not just an inconvenience. Reputable firms run this check as a matter of course; firms that resist it are telling you something.

Confirm the privilege and work-product mechanics

Information an investigator gathers at your direction is generally protected as work product, but the protection depends on how the engagement is structured. Retain the investigator through the law firm, not the client directly, and address reports to the attorney. Ask how the firm handles subpoenas for its files and whether it will notify you before producing anything, and put the confidentiality terms in the engagement letter.

Ask who actually does the work

Many firms sell with a senior investigator and staff the file with someone else. Ask for the name, license number, and testimony history of the person who will conduct the fieldwork, and confirm that person will not be swapped without your approval. If the firm cannot name the field investigator before you sign, that is a warning sign.

Watch Out Red flags during vetting: reluctance to provide a license number, no testimony history, no written retention policy for raw footage, resistance to a conflict check, and pricing quoted only verbally. Any one of these is a reason to keep looking.

Get references from litigators, not from clients

Ask for two or three references from attorneys who have used the investigator in a contested matter, and call them. Ask whether the documentation held up, whether the investigator was available for deposition prep, and whether they would use the investigator again where the evidence was likely to be challenged. A reference who praises personality but cannot speak to the work product is not useful.

The table below summarises the key vetting checks an attorney should run before signing with an investigator.

Check

What to confirm

Red flag

Licensing

Active state license and license number

Reluctance to provide the license number

Insurance

Professional liability and general liability policies

No insurance in place

Litigation experience

Testimony history and documented work in contested matters

No testimony history

Conflict check

Written confirmation of no conflicts with opposing counsel, parties or insurers

Resistance to running the check

Raw footage retention

A defined retention period and storage method

"As long as you need it"

Fieldwork staffing

Named field investigator with license and testimony history

Unnamed staff or swapping without approval

References

Two or three litigators who used the investigator in contested matters

References who cannot speak to the work product

Pricing, Retainers and Cost-Benefit Analysis

Investigation pricing is not standardized, and structure matters as much as rate. For a deeper look at the factors that drive Florida private investigator fees, read our pricing guide. To see what an investigator would charge for your situation, book a free consultation with our Melbourne, FL team. Most litigation investigators bill hourly plus expenses and require a retainer before work begins. The retainer is a draw against hours, not a fee, confirm in writing how unused retainer is handled, whether it is refundable, and what triggers replenishment.

What the invoice should itemize

Our Eyewitness team lists a surveillance retainer at $2,400.00 in its product catalog, with other retainer tiers ranging from $500.00 to $3,400.00.

The cost-benefit framework

  1. Compare against the alternative. The alternative is usually paralegal time, public-records requests, or living with the uncertainty. Paralegal time is cheaper per hour but cannot conduct field surveillance, cannot canvass a neighborhood, and cannot testify to what it observed.

Scope control is the real cost lever

The biggest driver of investigation cost is not the hourly rate, it is scope creep. A surveillance assignment that starts as "two days to check the claimant's activity level" becomes two weeks when the first two days produce nothing. Build a stop rule into the engagement: a defined number of hours or days, a reporting checkpoint, and a requirement to check in before exceeding the authorization. A good investigator welcomes the discipline.

When not to hire an investigator

Skip the investigator when the facts are already documented in discovery, when the claim value is too low to justify the spend, or when the only open question is legal rather than factual. Attorneys sometimes hire investigators to answer questions that a well-drafted interrogatory or request for production would have answered for free. Run the discovery first; hire the investigator for what discovery cannot reach.

Ethical and Legal Boundaries for Investigators

Confidentiality is equally important. To understand what privacy laws require and when disclosure is mandatory, read our confidentiality standards explained. Information gathered during an investigation is usually work product, and early disclosure can compromise the case. Agree in writing on who receives reports, how they are transmitted, and when information may be shared with third parties.

Booking Your Litigation Investigation with Eyewitness

The Eyewitness is led by a retired Law Enforcement Officer with 20 years of service and investigative experience dating back to 1992, and the team works across Florida on legal, insurance, and corporate matters. When you are ready to engage the firm, you can request an assignment directly.

Frequently Asked Questions

When should you hire a private investigator for litigation?

Consider hiring a private investigator when a case involves disputed facts. Your attorney can help decide whether an investigation is appropriate.

Can evidence collected by a private investigator be used in court?

Whether evidence can be used in court depends on the circumstances. Ask your attorney about the requirements that apply to your case.

How do you choose a private investigator for litigation?

Consider whether the investigator's experience is relevant to your case. The Eyewitness is led by a retired Law Enforcement Officer with 20 years of service and investigative experience dating back to 1992, including 17 years as a Traffic Homicide Investigator for The Florida Highway Patrol.

What should you give an investigator before an assignment?

Before contacting an investigator, consider what facts you need to establish and discuss your case with your attorney.

How much does a private investigator cost for a legal case?

Eyewitness Investigations & Surveillance lists pay-now options of $500.00, $1,000.00, $1,500.00, $2,000.00, and $3,400.00, as well as a $2,400.00 surveillance retainer. The catalog does not specify what each option covers.

Can a private investigator testify in court?

The Eyewitness specializes in traffic homicide and crash investigations. Ask your attorney whether expert testimony is appropriate for your case.

What is the difference between a witness location search and skip tracing?

The Eyewitness's verified service information does not specify witness-location searches or skip tracing. Ask your attorney what investigative services are relevant to your case.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page